Home » Columns » Perception and Reality in Today’s Political Climate: Jackman-Atkinson

Perception and Reality in Today’s Political Climate: Jackman-Atkinson

July 27, 2019 8:14 AM | Columns


By Kate Jackman-Atkinson, Neepawa Banner & Press

Justin Trudeau - Donald Trump

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau meets with U.S. President Donald Trump at the White House in Washington, D.C. on Thursday, June 20, 2019. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick)

As a middle of the road Canadian, I look at the political landscape and I’m concerned. Mostly, I’m concerned about the growing divisiveness I see elsewhere in the world and its creep into Canadian politics.

Canadians consume a lot of culture from outside our borders and we’re inundated with the current political climate in both America and Britain. Things aren’t quite so bad here and I always thought it was a function of our three-party system forcing parties to remember their centres. But I’m also seeing more memes, more instances where political opponents are being cast as a threat to democracy and less debate about actual policies. I can’t help but wonder, is it just that we’re slower to pick up on trends?

Whether it’s a case of perception or recognizing there’s a problem that needs to be solved, I came across a new study that gives me some hope. Last month, More in Common released a study called “The Perception Gap: How False Impressions are Pulling Americans Apart.” More in Common is an international initiative working to build societies and communities that are more resilient to the increasing threats of polarization and social division. It’s the third report in their Hidden Tribes Project, which seeks to better understand the forces driving the current climate of political polarization and tribalism in the United States. Yes, this is an American report, but their present could well be our future.

This study compared how much Republicans and Democrats think they disagree on issues, with how much they actually do. Participants were asked about the beliefs they thought their political opponents held and the major finding was that Americans don’t disagree on as much as they think they do. For example, Democrats imagine that only half (52 percent) of Republicans think that properly controlled immigration can be good for America, while the vast majority (85 percent) actually do. Democrats estimate that about half of Republicans (51 percent) would admit that racism is still a problem in America, when, in fact, it’s a view held by more than three-quarters of Republicans (79 percent). On the flip side, while Republicans think that only 48 percent of Democrats disagree with the statement, “most police are bad people,” 85 percent of them actually do. Republicans also estimate that just over half of Democrats (54 percent) feel proud to be American, while 82 percent of Democrats have a sense of national pride.

The study also looked at factors associated with a wider perception gap and found it was widest among those most active in politics, the people who should be better informed. The report found that those who post about politics on social media show a substantially larger perception gap than those who do not. But it’s not just engagement on social media, consumption of any form a media is associated with a wider perception gap.

Political beliefs exist on a spectrum and not surprisingly, the survey also found that the majority of respondents fall in the middle. This middle majority are characterized by being more ideologically flexible, support finding a political compromise, are fatigued by current politics and feel forgotten in political debate. They’re leaving the debate to those at the edges.

What’s the solution? With two elections coming up, maybe the solution is to talk to candidates from other parties. Political affiliation isn’t a disease, you won’t catch it from talking to someone you would never vote for and with whom you disagree on policy. The more we can understand what other Canadians see as a better future for our country, the better we can build a future that works to improve the lives of all Canadians.

Addressing divisiveness is important because if left unchecked, we’ll end up with fragmented groups that can’t work together. We’ll end up unable to find common ground and without common ground, there will be no progress.